It's nice how you got a frontpaged award for this. They should have those for flash submissions. I was a bit weirded out like you are that so many people like it. It isn't bad, it's just pretty strange. I guess if you had made the girl more attractive, I'd like it more? Lol, this seems to be an original character.
I am just more used to having a background on art pieces. If not, then they should at least move. It seemed like you were trying to make some metaphor with this. It's like the message was how we're consumed by darkness. I'm surprised it was as far back as 2008, because it looks pretty new!