Ericho's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[The Pink Elephant]

This is easily the best of all the Elephant submissions this year. It mostly helps that the animation is the best. I love how you have absolutely no idea what's going to happen next. It really makes you wonder if the elephant even is real, but it certainly seems to be. The best part was probably when he stepped on the tank which had the tankmen on it. It's probably the best elephant cartoon I've ever seen in my life!

I love how the music sets the tone perfectly. Elephants don't eat meat, so it was scary when the elephant ate that bird. Of course, it got more scary when he destroyed the city. Not so much an elephant in the room, just a pink elephant. It's still fantastic and unbelievably stylistic. I love how fluidly everything moves.

[Tits]

I thought this was pretty good. At first, it seems like it's just a silly cartoon to glamorize, well, tits. It actually is pretty catchy. What I didn't like is how the animation isn't that good. It seems a lot older than it really is. It makes me realize how stiff those women's nipples must be if they stick out like that.

The voices used in this were pretty good. For a song about being aroused, it actually had a kind of pleasant tone to it. I appreciate you trying to let people have a good time. Wow, I can't believe you're giving us links to download this song! There should be more details, though.

koit responds:

I agree for the most part.

I KNOW I'm not great at art and I'm only ok-ish at animation but where I do well is with ideas. So that's why these get pumped out looking like they do.

I've tried to get better but I can only draw how I can draw. Whilst I can improve shading etc (as someone mentioned below) there's only so far I can take my art.

[Batman : The Droppings]

Okay, that was one of the most random Batman cartoons I've ever seen in my life. I guess for the most part it was good, just very, very strange. I do appreciate how you try to put in some real good animation. I especially love Harley Quinn and how her boobs bounce around like that. I guess it would be gauche of me to be reminded of the "Dark Knight Rises" movie coming out this year. I was, anyway.

I notice El-Cid wasn't credited in the credits, but whatever. The voices were pretty spot on and they truly captured the insanity and stupidity of this cartoon. It is pretty satisfying to just throw stuff and crush your enemy like that. Everyone put in a decent amount of effort for this. That's a strange love triangle.

RicePirate responds:

El-cid did the splash page art, that i found in the art portal. And he's credited in the bottom corner of the splash page :)

[Stikfas T]

I guess the two main characters were supposed to be Optimus Prime and Megatron. It seems like this could have been something interesting, but it wasn't. Congradulations on having such a high score on this of course for some reason. I just appreciate people who make longer stuff. The stop motion effects didn't seem all that long. It didn't seem any different than what most people did.

The typed words were done pretty poorly too. I wish Livecorpse would have been credited under the "Credits & Info" part. I also had no idea what the title meant. From that, I assumed it was going to have stick figures. This did little for me.

[Dr Whooves & Assistant 2]

I didn't like this one as much as the first, probably because it didn't seem as fresh or anything. So wait, you're not the guy who made the original audio series? I thought you were. Anyway, it seems like this is great and fulfilling everything you could want in a Doctor Whooves and Assistant cartoon. It's great to see two great characters become used like this. I think that character's name might be Ditzy Doo now instead of Derpy.

It's because some soccer mom was offended by the fact that a pony was called "Derpy". It's great to see this series back. I was in no way expecting so much to go on, particularly with him meeting up with all the other ponies. It's nice to see how this turns out. The sprite stuff at the end is cute too.

[The Tale of Lambert]

This isn't that good, but it's still enjoyable. It's always nice to be able to listen to that awesome "Mad World" song. What I didn't understand was why you even decided to make this a Madness flash in the first place. It doesn't have much violence and doesn't seem to connect with the theme well. The only violence was him dying with the car. I guess it goes to show that Madness Combat can create any deriavitive material.

I do think this is a fairly good story that is being told. It's the kind of thing that most ordinary people can associate themselves with. Hopefully, we'll all be able to have some joy and success in our lives. Congradulations on getting such a high rating! It seems like every Madness flash is in the Top 50 now.

Rapheus responds:

That's pretty much what I was going for. Madness but not. This animation takes place in my MadSeth universe, where I try to shoehorn in a story, not just a massive kill count. I very much appreciate your review, though.

Sometimes we must go against the grain and do what isn't orthodox.

[War of the Shyguys]

WOAH, I'm so glad you told me about this! This is one of the most awesome flashes I've seen in a long time! I think the main thing that makes it so good is how fantastic the graphics and designs are. It's like one minute everything is done in sprites while the next it's done with hand drawn stuff. You rarely see a submission use both of those things prominently. I freaking loved the action and characters in this.

I guess not a single bit of a Shyguy's body is known. I appreciate the wide variety of voices. It's also great that you dedicated this to Randy Solem because he's such an awesome guy who deserves this tribute. It does seem like something he would work on. You are right, nostalgia will never die for neither him nor sprite games. It's a great cartoon!

Eastbeast responds:

Thanks I really appreciate your review, especially since you've been around NG enough to know about it's history. Randy Solem passed away about 3/4ths of the way through the production of this flash, near completion I realized I probably would never have found out about spriting, much less Newgrounds without his work. His epic, no boundary ideas were big inspiration on this piece, and a lot of my work in general. I hope to move on and make the next flash with entirely drawn animation, although the feeling of a big epic piece will still be there. Thanks for the review, it means a lot that you liked it. maybe you'll find out my interpretation of the shyguy's face in the next one? -Esty

[Rise of chaos episode 1]

I thought you did try to have more of a story than some of your other work. What I didn't like was how this just seemed to go on too long. There wasn't even a single action scene! Don't get me wrong, emotional stuff it good too, but it just doesn't add up to much here. I did think the music was pretty good. I think the sprite work is alright, but it doesn't really go anywhere.

Maybe the finale with the action will make up for this. This was okay, not something I would recommend. There should have been more movement and better written text. I can see how you were influenced by SMBZ for this. Alvin-Earthworom was actually inspired by Kirbopher's TTA series.

Punisher33 responds:

This is going to slowly lead up to the action scenes sense it's going to be explaining origins. not much action right away. it builds up to it. trust me. episode 2 is gonna be crazy insane. and very involved.

[Aqua HD]

I can certianly see why this took such a long time to make. I had no idea you had created something so wonderful. What really strikes me as awesome about this is how you have shown such strong lines. You really showed us how an outline of a character can tell you a lot about him. I love the music and how fluid it moves the story along. Given the story's theme, it kind of moves fluidly literally.

I couldn't help but think that the cat looked like a rabbit in some parts. It's still a wonderful cartoon and something everyone should see. While it had no dialogue, I could still get into the story. Congrations on your success. You made something great!

[Birthday 21]

Yeah, I remember when I turned 21 too. I think the only thing you can't do yet is drive a rental car, which you have to wait until 23. Then again, I am 23 myself! Of course, this was a great cartoon. I feel it's one of your submissions where we really get in your head and understand what's going on in your life. You are one of the most prolific creators on this website of course.

I am sure you will find love someday. Hey, maybe your female friend, eh, I'm just kidding. I like how you (as a cartoon character) looked so stern all the time while maintaing a silly overtone. Here's to more years of making great cartoons! With your other birthdays being celebrated, it doesn't look like you'll be retiring anytime soon.